Grief, in these days where the sun is low and white, hits like the snow tires of a heavy Ford pickup. It rolls over me slowly and waits for the weight to break, leaving again with the crunch of gravel and sleet. There are many things to love and cherish, and it is thanks to those things that this season is bearable. Still, the backbone of winter lives in calcified sorrows, a vertebrae of things that seem to spring up only when the leaves abandon us, the ground loses its thickness, and the wren stops.
Would it be so bad to admit that this grief is for the childhood dogs I grew up with? I don’t think I will ever truly stop missing them, remembering them, mistaking the scratch of a branch at the window for their smallfooted bodies waiting to come back inside. The idea of a dog being ‘just a dog’ is a foreign concept to me, despite having heard those words time and time again in my life.
Sweet things — it was only years ago, some hot summer, the sun baking us in the metal of our boat. My family, a few cousins, and me, on a heat wave weekend. The waters were choppy and unforgiving, but T-bone and Minnie had good lake legs. They knew how to move around, how to stand, when to sit, and when to brace themselves. They had always been the best deckhands on the Cobalt, but as the years bore on in those palmetto days, I saw the change. The new slowness, the minor struggle you could only identify when really searching for it. Before the days were over, though, they would have managed to steal a few chips from my mama. If I had known what times would be the last, I would’ve given them a few more. I would’ve laid by them on the brown floor of the boat the whole ride.
I try to fill these days with reading, much as I do any other time of the year, but in the winter with more of a desperation. I have been digging through Mary Oliver’s Devotions. Containing some of her best work across many of her different publications, there was a poem that stuck with me the most: Her Grave, which hails from her 2013 poetry collection Dog Songs.
She would come back, dripping thick water, from the green bog.
She would fall at my feet, she would draw the black skin
from her gums, in a hideous and wonderful smile —
and I would rub my hands over her pricked ears and her
cunning elbows,
And I would hug the barrel of her body, amazed at the unassuming
perfect arch of her neck.
Dog Songs details the canine companions of Oliver’s life, and expresses the profound love and joy they brought her in details that are etched in a sort of nostalgia. Each poem recalls a dog that she can only continue to love in memory or retrospect. In the language of each poem are intimate recollections of not just their habits and personalities, but their features, their bodies, and the things about each of them that brought a familiarity even in their passing. Her Grave is one of the longest and most heartbreaking of the collection, as she remembers fondly the last days of her dog, Luke.
It took four of us to carry her into the woods.
We did not think of music,
but, anyway, it began to rain
slowly.
Her wolfish, invitational, half-pounce.
Her great and lordly satisfaction at having chased something.
My great and lordly satisfaction at her splash
of happiness as she barged
through the pitch pines swiping my face with her
wild, slightly mossy tongue.
It is through even the smallest of descriptions that she gives us the devoted imagery of Luke, staving away from any kind of apathetic ennui. It makes sense that Oliver would hone in on furry friends when a great majority of her writing is based in the natural world. However, instead of basing us in her usual lakes, mountains, or forests, we find ourselves in the simple places we often are with our pets. Fields, kitchens, bathrooms. For Her Grave, it is in the hardest of these: those last days, and a resting place.
Does the hummingbird think he himself invented his crimson throat?
He is wiser than that, I think.
A dog lives fifteen years, if you’re lucky.
Do the cranes crying out in the high clouds
think it is all their own music?
A dog comes to you and lives with you in your own house, but you
do not therefore own her, as you do not own the rain, or the
trees, or the laws which pertain to them.
Does the bear wandering in the autumn up the side of the hill
think all by herself she has imagined the refuge and the refreshment
of her long slumber?
A dog can never tell you what she knows from the
smells of the world, but you know, watching her, that you know
almost nothing.
It was in this section that I had to sit with what Oliver was writing. I didn’t understand why she was referencing these animals and critters, or what they meant. I understood that we did not truly own our dogs, but what did that mean here?
What I did know is that losing a dog is a special grief. And I think that, with human life, we know it to be a fact that we are all going to be gone somehow, some way. From the first time your parents take you by the shoulders and explain that someone, for some reason, is gone forever. From biology classes, from the nightly news, from the interstate, from cemeteries, and from boating accidents. I forgot, though, that this inevitable fate also applies to dogs. As a child there was no such thing as death because I had just barely begun to live. I had always navigated this life with a good dog at my ankles, barking and squirming happily while I giggled and ran with my arms outstretched — a memory that sprawls as far as the bermuda grass that grows to the edge of the cypress trees.
What I came to understand, after pouring over this poem over and over, is that not only do we not truly own our dogs, but they themselves understand this. We can own them, sure, on paper, or even in relationships that bear strong threads that seem impossible to break, completely inseparable. But they are always going to be part of where they originally came, even as we pamper them, adore them, and hold them close. And, somehow, this realization came as a comfort.
She roved ahead of me through the fields, yet would come back, or
wait for me, or be somewhere.
Now she is buried under the pines.
Nor will I argue it, or pray for anything but modesty, and
not to be angry.
I held a lot of frustration when I lost the second of my two dogs. While the first passed peacefully in sleep, the second was not the same. I walked around for weeks with a pent up anger that was melded together in hot tears. While that anger has cooled and replaced itself with acceptance, this poem put me further into something closer to understanding, rather than just blind affirmation. While it did seem she had been taken from me unfairly, there is somewhere where she runs through the grass, finds no faults in her little body, and is overjoyed just to be somewhere, the two of them together.
Through the trees there is the sound of the wind, palavering.
The smell of the pine needles, what is it but a taste
of the infallible energies?
How strong was her dark body!
How apt is her grave place.
How beautiful is her unshakable sleep.
Finally,
the slick mountains of love break
over us.
Oliver’s love for Luke, just like my own for my dogs, is coated by the knowledge that there is nothing to be done in loss, even as you wish for a way to change things. A love so impeccable and invincible that even a mountain, tall and daunting, breaks softly at the touch of a pure love like a dog’s love. When they leave us, it is not a loss or a derision — rather, it is a thankfulness, a love that sticks around. You may spend all these years without them after, but they spent all of theirs with you. That, for them, is all they need. They are always to be found in the mountains, in the nature they loved in living, in all the corners they once kept.
